Difference between revisions of "Talk:Coalition of Anti-Capitalist Economies/Archive"

From NSwiki, the NationStates encyclopedia.
Jump to: navigation, search
Line 17: Line 17:
 
# I don't think this article meets the standard of "one of the finest examples of NSwiki's work."  There's a lot that could be said about CACE, and this article doesn't do it justice in my opinion.  Is CACE a subject that could get a featured article on it?  Yes.  Does the article at present qualify it for featured status?  No. --[[User:Goobergunch|Goobergunch]]|[[User talk:Goobergunch|?]] 17:38, 24 Oct 2004 (GMT)
 
# I don't think this article meets the standard of "one of the finest examples of NSwiki's work."  There's a lot that could be said about CACE, and this article doesn't do it justice in my opinion.  Is CACE a subject that could get a featured article on it?  Yes.  Does the article at present qualify it for featured status?  No. --[[User:Goobergunch|Goobergunch]]|[[User talk:Goobergunch|?]] 17:38, 24 Oct 2004 (GMT)
 
# I don't really have an opinion on the page, but it seems to me it was nominated due to its significance to the game, not the wiki.  That's not reason for a FAC nomination, IMO.  [[User:Frisbeeteria|&rarr; ''Frisbeeteria'']] [[User talk:Frisbeeteria|&Theta;<small>talk</small>]] 17:57, 24 Oct 2004 (GMT)
 
# I don't really have an opinion on the page, but it seems to me it was nominated due to its significance to the game, not the wiki.  That's not reason for a FAC nomination, IMO.  [[User:Frisbeeteria|&rarr; ''Frisbeeteria'']] [[User talk:Frisbeeteria|&Theta;<small>talk</small>]] 17:57, 24 Oct 2004 (GMT)
#I don't really think this article is deserving of a featured article nomination. It just doesn't seem long enough. [[User:International Racing]]
+
#I don't really think this article is deserving of a featured article nomination. It just doesn't seem long enough. [[User:International Racing|International Racing]]
  
 
'''Neutral'''
 
'''Neutral'''

Revision as of 14:28, 24 October 2004

Since we're all a bunch of red bastards, the CACE is going to keep our red background, thanks. --Pudding


Let's not start editing other people's entries to make petty points. I'm refereing to the edit that said that CACE makes it's decisions behind closed doors. Utter rubbish. A few people may think that way because they're been banned from the site for getting their friends to aqcuire passwords and using them to gain access to the secutiry forum - note: security, not policy - or that users are now required to register on the CACE forums before gaining acces to them. No restirictions are placed on registration (unless you're banned for the aforementioned reasons).

So please, let's not go down this road or the site will become useless.

--Celdonia 13:31, 15 Oct 2004 (GMT)

Coalition of Anti-Capitalist Economies FAC Vote (1/2/0)

  • Just a request - could people please remember to sign their votes with 4 tildes (~~~~) and update the vote tally when they vote? Thanks. --Goobergunch

Support

  1. Nominated by me as an historically significant, and very log standing alliance --Celdonia 17:18, 24 Oct 2004 (GMT)

Oppose

  1. It seems to me a featured article should be of high quality and this is a rather short entry that does not really stand out one way or the other. The "political significance" should make no difference IMO. If it had a history and an overview of policies and all that it would be a different matter. -- |Knoot|KNOOtalk 17:28, 24 Oct 2004 (GMT)
  2. I don't think this article meets the standard of "one of the finest examples of NSwiki's work." There's a lot that could be said about CACE, and this article doesn't do it justice in my opinion. Is CACE a subject that could get a featured article on it? Yes. Does the article at present qualify it for featured status? No. --Goobergunch|? 17:38, 24 Oct 2004 (GMT)
  3. I don't really have an opinion on the page, but it seems to me it was nominated due to its significance to the game, not the wiki. That's not reason for a FAC nomination, IMO. Frisbeeteria Θtalk 17:57, 24 Oct 2004 (GMT)
  4. I don't really think this article is deserving of a featured article nomination. It just doesn't seem long enough. International Racing

Neutral

Comments/Questions