Difference between revisions of "Talk:Marion oaks 2/FAC"
From NSwiki, the NationStates encyclopedia.
Rejistania (Talk | contribs) m |
|||
| (19 intermediate revisions by 11 users not shown) | |||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
| − | <h3> | + | :This is an archive of a closed FAC vote. The decision of the vote was '''not to feature'''. Please do not edit this article, as the discussion is no longer live. |
| + | |||
| + | <h3> Marion oaks 2 FAC Vote (1/11/0) </h3> | ||
''Please remember to sign your votes with 4 tildes ( ~~~~) and update the vote tally when you vote.'' | ''Please remember to sign your votes with 4 tildes ( ~~~~) and update the vote tally when you vote.'' | ||
'''Support''' | '''Support''' | ||
| − | # Marion oaks 2 | + | # See below for my Comment[[User:Marion oaks 2|Marion oaks 2]] 08:26, July 20th 2006 (EST) |
'''Oppose''' | '''Oppose''' | ||
# Self nominations {CENSORED}! Also this page is not really ready to be FACed yet... (also: Please remember to sign your votes with 4 tildes) [[User:Rejistania|Rejistania]] 18:15, 18 July 2006 (GMT) | # Self nominations {CENSORED}! Also this page is not really ready to be FACed yet... (also: Please remember to sign your votes with 4 tildes) [[User:Rejistania|Rejistania]] 18:15, 18 July 2006 (GMT) | ||
| − | # | + | # See above. Also, sections are not made properly and the name of the nation is capitalized as "Marion Oaks 2" in some places and "Marion oaks 2" in others. [[User:Myroria|Myroria]] 23:56, 30 July 2006 (GMT) |
| + | # Just not good enough to be a featured article, and self-nomination tut tut! [[User:The Islands of Qutar|The Islands of Qutar]] 00:08, 15 August 2006 (GMT) | ||
| + | #I have no objection to self-nominations. I have objections to the untidy sprawl on this page. Not even close to feature status - being "full of facts" is insufficient justification. [[Special:Contributions/Gruenberg2|<font color="blue">~</font>]][[User:Gruenberg2|<font color="green">Gruen</font>]][[User talk:Gruenberg2|<font color="red">2alk</font>]] 10:40, 6 September 2006 (GMT) | ||
| + | #Nope. Not at all. Half the article is a football team roster. No paragraphs at all. [[User:Ceorana|''C''eoran]]<sub>[[User talk:Ceorana|'''''<span style="color:red">t</span>''''']]</sub>[[User:Ceorana|a]] 02:38, 7 September 2006 (GMT) | ||
| + | #You must be joking, right? This is a mockery of the system if I ever saw one... Agreed with Ceo, there's just nothing in here that makes it feature-worthy - it's a football roster and unsightly codification. (( [[User:Pacitalia|<font color="navy">Paci</font>]][[User_talk:Pacitalia|<font color="green">'''talk'''</font>]][[User:Pacitalia|<font color="red">ia</font>]] )) <small>Time sent:</small> 08:04, 1 October 2006 (GMT) | ||
| + | # There's nothing here of worth. Sorry, but heck no. [[User:Spaam|Spaam]] 07:12, 13 October 2006 (GMT) | ||
| + | # This article is really just a big list with headders --[[User:Kanami|Kanami]] 21:08, 13 October 2006 (GMT) | ||
| + | # Strongly opposed, agreed with other opposition comments. '''[[Jey|<font color="blue"><sup>J</sup></font>]][[User:Jey|<font color="red">e</font>]][[User_talk:Jey|<font color="green"><sub>y</sub></font>]][[Special:Contributions/Jey|<font color="purple"><sup>°</sup></font>]]''' 22:13, 14 October 2006 (GMT) | ||
| + | # Very sorry, but no. I've no doubt you've put effort into this, but it's still mainly a... list of lists. The only non-sports information on the nation itself is fragmented (top and lower down), and much of it is pasted from your NS page, which isn't very original. Also, you've thrown player info into the mix, blurring the distinction between the in-game nation and the "nation-in-a-game". I would recommend adding a lot more on the nation itself, not just its sports. Tell us about its people, culture, history, geography, government, wherever your creativity takes you. [[User:Aridd|Aridd]] 23:35, 14 October 2006 (GMT) | ||
| + | # I'm not trying to offend anyone, but this is a poor quality article. It does not even deserve to be nominated. --'''[[Swilatia|<font color="red">sw</font>]][[User:Swilatia|<font color="green">il</font>]][[User Talk: Swilatia|<font color= "yellow">at</font>]][[Special:Contributions/Swilatia|<font color="blue">ia</font>]]''' 15:50, 15 October 2006 (GMT) | ||
'''Neutral''' | '''Neutral''' | ||
| Line 13: | Line 24: | ||
'''Comments/Questions''' | '''Comments/Questions''' | ||
| − | Self Nomination. I Nominated This Because i spent long hours updating it and links that come out of it. Also it is Frequently Updated and is full of facts. Thats why i think this should be a Featured Article. Marion oaks 2 [[User:Marion oaks 2|Marion oaks 2]] | + | Self Nomination. I Nominated This Because i spent long hours updating it and links that come out of it. Also it is Frequently Updated and is full of facts. Thats why i think this should be a Featured Article. Marion oaks 2 [[User:Marion oaks 2|Marion oaks 2]] 3:40, 12 July 2006 (EST) |
| + | |||
| + | I'm archiving this, as the vote is 1/11/0 to oppose. [[User:Ceorana|''C''eoran]]<sub>[[User talk:Ceorana|'''''<span style="color:red">t</span>''''']]</sub>[[User:Ceorana|a]] 18:49, 15 October 2006 (GMT) | ||
Latest revision as of 14:49, 15 October 2006
- This is an archive of a closed FAC vote. The decision of the vote was not to feature. Please do not edit this article, as the discussion is no longer live.
Marion oaks 2 FAC Vote (1/11/0)
Please remember to sign your votes with 4 tildes ( ~~~~) and update the vote tally when you vote.
Support
- See below for my CommentMarion oaks 2 08:26, July 20th 2006 (EST)
Oppose
- Self nominations {CENSORED}! Also this page is not really ready to be FACed yet... (also: Please remember to sign your votes with 4 tildes) Rejistania 18:15, 18 July 2006 (GMT)
- See above. Also, sections are not made properly and the name of the nation is capitalized as "Marion Oaks 2" in some places and "Marion oaks 2" in others. Myroria 23:56, 30 July 2006 (GMT)
- Just not good enough to be a featured article, and self-nomination tut tut! The Islands of Qutar 00:08, 15 August 2006 (GMT)
- I have no objection to self-nominations. I have objections to the untidy sprawl on this page. Not even close to feature status - being "full of facts" is insufficient justification. ~Gruen2alk 10:40, 6 September 2006 (GMT)
- Nope. Not at all. Half the article is a football team roster. No paragraphs at all. Ceoranta 02:38, 7 September 2006 (GMT)
- You must be joking, right? This is a mockery of the system if I ever saw one... Agreed with Ceo, there's just nothing in here that makes it feature-worthy - it's a football roster and unsightly codification. (( Pacitalkia )) Time sent: 08:04, 1 October 2006 (GMT)
- There's nothing here of worth. Sorry, but heck no. Spaam 07:12, 13 October 2006 (GMT)
- This article is really just a big list with headders --Kanami 21:08, 13 October 2006 (GMT)
- Strongly opposed, agreed with other opposition comments. Jey° 22:13, 14 October 2006 (GMT)
- Very sorry, but no. I've no doubt you've put effort into this, but it's still mainly a... list of lists. The only non-sports information on the nation itself is fragmented (top and lower down), and much of it is pasted from your NS page, which isn't very original. Also, you've thrown player info into the mix, blurring the distinction between the in-game nation and the "nation-in-a-game". I would recommend adding a lot more on the nation itself, not just its sports. Tell us about its people, culture, history, geography, government, wherever your creativity takes you. Aridd 23:35, 14 October 2006 (GMT)
- I'm not trying to offend anyone, but this is a poor quality article. It does not even deserve to be nominated. --swilatia 15:50, 15 October 2006 (GMT)
Neutral
Comments/Questions Self Nomination. I Nominated This Because i spent long hours updating it and links that come out of it. Also it is Frequently Updated and is full of facts. Thats why i think this should be a Featured Article. Marion oaks 2 Marion oaks 2 3:40, 12 July 2006 (EST)
I'm archiving this, as the vote is 1/11/0 to oppose. Ceoranta 18:49, 15 October 2006 (GMT)
